General Information |
|
| Study Number: | TPF-5(519) |
| Former Study Number: | TPF-5(377) |
| Lead Organization: | Indiana Department of Transportation |
| Solicitation Number: | 1589 |
| Partners: | CA, CT, GADOT, MN, MS, NC, OH, PADOT, TX, UT, WI |
| Status: | Cleared by FHWA |
| Est. Completion Date: | |
| Contract/Other Number: | |
| Last Updated: | Jan 03, 2025 |
| Contract End Date: | |
Financial Summary |
|
| Contract Amount: | |
| Suggested Contribution: | |
| Total Commitments Received: | $1,260,000.00 |
| 100% SP&R Approval: | Approved |
Contact Information |
|||
| Lead Study Contact(s): | Tommy Nantung | ||
| tnantung@indot.in.gov | |||
| Phone: 765-463-1521 ext 248 | |||
| FHWA Technical Liaison(s): | Richard Denney | ||
| Richard.Denney@dot.gov | |||
| Phone: 410-962-4796 | |||
| Study Champion(s): | Jim Sturdevant | ||
| jsturdevant@indot.in.gov | |||
| Phone: 317-899-8617 | |||
| Organization | Year | Commitments | Technical Contact Name | Funding Contact Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| California Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Michael Robinson | Sang Le |
| California Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Michael Robinson | Sang Le |
| California Department of Transportation | 2026 | $40,000.00 | Michael Robinson | Sang Le |
| California Department of Transportation | 2027 | $40,000.00 | Michael Robinson | Sang Le |
| Connecticut Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Kevin Danh | Mauricio Garcia-Theran |
| Connecticut Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Kevin Danh | Mauricio Garcia-Theran |
| Connecticut Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Kevin Danh | Mauricio Garcia-Theran |
| Connecticut Department of Transportation | 2026 | $40,000.00 | Kevin Danh | Mauricio Garcia-Theran |
| Georgia Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Justin Hatch | Brennan Roney |
| Georgia Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Justin Hatch | Brennan Roney |
| Georgia Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Justin Hatch | Brennan Roney |
| Minnesota Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Derek Lehrke | Leif Halverson |
| Minnesota Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Derek Lehrke | Leif Halverson |
| Minnesota Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Derek Lehrke | Leif Halverson |
| Mississippi Department of Transportation | 2023 | $30,000.00 | James Sullivan | Robert Vance |
| Mississippi Department of Transportation | 2024 | $30,000.00 | James Sullivan | Robert Vance |
| North Carolina Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Meghan LeBlanc | Curtis Bradley |
| North Carolina Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Meghan LeBlanc | Curtis Bradley |
| North Carolina Department of Transportation | 2026 | $40,000.00 | Meghan LeBlanc | Curtis Bradley |
| Ohio Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Charles Fisher | General Research |
| Ohio Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Charles Fisher | General Research |
| Ohio Department of Transportation | 2026 | $40,000.00 | Charles Fisher | General Research |
| Pennsylvania Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Steve Gault | Evan Zeiders |
| Pennsylvania Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Steve Gault | Evan Zeiders |
| Pennsylvania Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Steve Gault | Evan Zeiders |
| Texas Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Tomas Lindheimer | Ned Mattila |
| Texas Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Tomas Lindheimer | Ned Mattila |
| Texas Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Tomas Lindheimer | Ned Mattila |
| Utah Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Mark Taylor | David Stevens |
| Utah Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Mark Taylor | David Stevens |
| Utah Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Mark Taylor | David Stevens |
| Wisconsin Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Jeremy Iwen | Evelyn Bromberg |
The Pooled Fund Project TPF-5(377) is led by Indiana and includes participation from FHWA, California, Connecticut, Georgia, Minnesota, NorthCarolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, Utah, andWisconsin.The projectdevelopedmethodologiesandtoolsforusinghighresolutionvehicletrajectorydata tocompute enhanced traffic signal performance measures.Significant outcomes from the study are listed at the end of this document in the reference section.
The Indiana led pooled fund traffic signal research projects have a strong history of implementation. The first study, TPF-5(259), was recognized by EDC 4 and virtually all controllers now provide high resolution data logging. There is a strong commercial base of advanced traffic signal performance measureproviders.Thetechnicalreportsfrom TPF-5(259)listedbelowarewidelydistributedandcited.
· PerformanceMeasuresforTrafficSignalSystems:AnOutcome-OrientedApproach. http://dx.doi.org/10.5703/1288284315333
· IntegratingTrafficSignalPerformanceMeasuresintoAgencyBusinessProcesses. http://dx.doi.org/10.5703/1288284316063
Similarly,TPF-5(377)isnowstimulatingasecondgenerationofcommercialimplementationoftrajectory based traffic signal performance measures.The current TPF-5(377) project end date is June 20, 2023.
DuringtheApril2022TPF-5(377) Pooled Fund StudyPanelMeetinginColumbus,OH,participatingstatesexpressedinterestin developing a new study led by a neutral state/academic partner in the following areas:
1. Broadeningperformancemeasurestoadditionalmodesthatareimpactedbytrafficsignal systems, particularly transit and pedestrians.
2. Identifyingusecasesforenhancedprobedatabeyond thecurrenttrajectoryandhard braking/hard acceleration data.
3. IntegratedAnalysisofHigh-resControllerDataandTrajectoryProbeData
Theseinitiativeswouldcomplementandexpandthepastworkthemulti-stateteamhas doneinthe area of enhanced traffic signal performance measures using connected vehicle data.
1. Identifycommercialprobedatasets thatareavailableandprocureonemonthof probedatafor each participating state. This task is important as there has been substantial growth in connected vehicle data attributes since TPF-5(377) was initiated.In addition to passenger car trajectoriesandhardbraking,therearenowdata elementsthat includefinergradationsofhard braking, finer gradations of acceleration, traction control (winter conditions), commercial truck trajectories,andelectricvehicles.Inconsultationwiththepanel,theresearchteamwillacquire as broad and inclusive connected vehicle data as financially feasible.
2. Perform penetration analysis of connected vehicle data to understand how it varies by state. There is broad interest in ensuring that the connected vehicle is representative and has sufficient penetration to provide accurate performance measures.The previous pooled fund study looked at penetration of passenger cars in the participating states (Figure 1) in August 2021.Therewasconsiderableregionalvariation(Figure2).Apreliminaryanalysisofconnected
trucksdata inIndiana,indicatedthatconnected truck datashouldalsobeconsideredtoincrease penetration.Although truck data is relatively modest during peak hours, including truck data provides a more representative analysis of how a traffic signal performs.
3. Updateperformancemeasureanalysistechniquestoexaminehowmixofcommercial vehicles and passenger cars impact a traffic signal operation.For many decades, the highway capacity manualhasusedtheheavevehicle(fhv)adjustmentfactor.However,thevalidationonthishas been quite limited.We now have an opportunity to evaluate the impact of heavy vehicles on traffic signals at scale.
4. Identify transit agencies in participating states that have AVL/connected bus data available to sharewithresearchteam.Thistaskisimportantas theinfrastructurebillhasseveralprograms that touch both transit and traffic signal systems so it is important to enhance performance measure analysis to be inclusive of transit vehicles.We anticipate this providing an important framework for factual and constructive dialog between traffic signal operators and transit operators.For example, we now have the ability to directly compare transit operating performance measures with passenger cars and trucks operating in the same stream.Figure 4 illustrates a heatmap showing bus performance measures that can be overlayed with traffic signal performance measures to identify if there are opportunities to improve traffic signal operation.
5. Integratetrajectorydataandhighresolutiondata tocharacterizehowperformancemeasures suchassplitfailureandarrival ongreenvarydepending ifthey arecalculatedusing trajectory data or traditional high resolution data. This will be important to document so agencies that have well established ATSPM programs using traditional hi-res data can easily transition to trajectory based ATSPM.
6. Integrate trajectory data and high resolution controller data for multi-modal analysis.Pedestrian push button information have long been available in hi-resolution logs, but they do not provide demand level data.Many of the new camera systems (such as Miovision) can providereasonablemeasurementofpedestrianmovementsincrosswalks.Thistaskwilllookat opportunities to integrate traffic signal data, such as pedestrian movements, with trajectory based traffic signal performance measures so that there is an opportunity for constructive and factual dialog on how to most effectively operate traffic signals in areas where pedestrian demand varies by time and location.
7. Preparefinal report.
Funding requested: $120,000($40,000peryearforthreeyears)fromeachparticipatingstate.
Proposed starting date: January1,2023
Please see the enclosed proposal.
General Information |
|
| Study Number: | TPF-5(519) |
| Lead Organization: | Indiana Department of Transportation |
| Solicitation Number: | 1589 |
| Partners: | CA, CT, GADOT, MN, MS, NC, OH, PADOT, TX, UT, WI |
| Status: | Cleared by FHWA |
| Est. Completion Date: | |
| Contract/Other Number: | |
| Last Updated: | Jan 03, 2025 |
| Contract End Date: | |
Financial Summary |
|
| Contract Amount: | |
| Total Commitments Received: | $1,260,000.00 |
| 100% SP&R Approval: | |
Contact Information |
|||
| Lead Study Contact(s): | Tommy Nantung | ||
| tnantung@indot.in.gov | |||
| Phone: 765-463-1521 ext 248 | |||
| FHWA Technical Liaison(s): | Richard Denney | ||
| Richard.Denney@dot.gov | |||
| Phone: 410-962-4796 | |||
| Organization | Year | Commitments | Technical Contact Name | Funding Contact Name | Contact Number | Email Address |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| California Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Michael Robinson | Sang Le | (916)701-3998 | sang.le@dot.ca.gov |
| California Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Michael Robinson | Sang Le | (916)701-3998 | sang.le@dot.ca.gov |
| California Department of Transportation | 2026 | $40,000.00 | Michael Robinson | Sang Le | (916)701-3998 | sang.le@dot.ca.gov |
| California Department of Transportation | 2027 | $40,000.00 | Michael Robinson | Sang Le | (916)701-3998 | sang.le@dot.ca.gov |
| Connecticut Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Kevin Danh | Mauricio Garcia-Theran | 860-594-2015 | mauricio.garcia-theran@ct.gov |
| Connecticut Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Kevin Danh | Mauricio Garcia-Theran | 860-594-2015 | mauricio.garcia-theran@ct.gov |
| Connecticut Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Kevin Danh | Mauricio Garcia-Theran | 860-594-2015 | mauricio.garcia-theran@ct.gov |
| Connecticut Department of Transportation | 2026 | $40,000.00 | Kevin Danh | Mauricio Garcia-Theran | 860-594-2015 | mauricio.garcia-theran@ct.gov |
| Georgia Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Justin Hatch | Brennan Roney | 404-347-0595 | broney@dot.ga.gov |
| Georgia Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Justin Hatch | Brennan Roney | 404-347-0595 | broney@dot.ga.gov |
| Georgia Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Justin Hatch | Brennan Roney | 404-347-0595 | broney@dot.ga.gov |
| Minnesota Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Derek Lehrke | Leif Halverson | 651-366-3786 | Leif.Halverson@state.mn.us |
| Minnesota Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Derek Lehrke | Leif Halverson | 651-366-3786 | Leif.Halverson@state.mn.us |
| Minnesota Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Derek Lehrke | Leif Halverson | 651-366-3786 | Leif.Halverson@state.mn.us |
| Mississippi Department of Transportation | 2023 | $30,000.00 | James Sullivan | Robert Vance | RVance@mdot.ms.gov | |
| Mississippi Department of Transportation | 2024 | $30,000.00 | James Sullivan | Robert Vance | RVance@mdot.ms.gov | |
| North Carolina Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Meghan LeBlanc | Curtis Bradley | 919-707-6661 | cbradley8@ncdot.gov |
| North Carolina Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Meghan LeBlanc | Curtis Bradley | 919-707-6661 | cbradley8@ncdot.gov |
| North Carolina Department of Transportation | 2026 | $40,000.00 | Meghan LeBlanc | Curtis Bradley | 919-707-6661 | cbradley8@ncdot.gov |
| Ohio Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Charles Fisher | General Research | 614-644-8135 | Research@dot.state.oh.us |
| Ohio Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Charles Fisher | General Research | 614-644-8135 | Research@dot.state.oh.us |
| Ohio Department of Transportation | 2026 | $40,000.00 | Charles Fisher | General Research | 614-644-8135 | Research@dot.state.oh.us |
| Pennsylvania Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Steve Gault | Evan Zeiders | 717-787-8460 | evzeiders@pa.gov |
| Pennsylvania Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Steve Gault | Evan Zeiders | 717-787-8460 | evzeiders@pa.gov |
| Pennsylvania Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Steve Gault | Evan Zeiders | 717-787-8460 | evzeiders@pa.gov |
| Texas Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Tomas Lindheimer | Ned Mattila | 512-221-3450 | ned.mattila@txdot.gov |
| Texas Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Tomas Lindheimer | Ned Mattila | 512-221-3450 | ned.mattila@txdot.gov |
| Texas Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Tomas Lindheimer | Ned Mattila | 512-221-3450 | ned.mattila@txdot.gov |
| Utah Department of Transportation | 2023 | $40,000.00 | Mark Taylor | David Stevens | 801-589-8340 | davidstevens@utah.gov |
| Utah Department of Transportation | 2024 | $40,000.00 | Mark Taylor | David Stevens | 801-589-8340 | davidstevens@utah.gov |
| Utah Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Mark Taylor | David Stevens | 801-589-8340 | davidstevens@utah.gov |
| Wisconsin Department of Transportation | 2025 | $40,000.00 | Jeremy Iwen | Evelyn Bromberg | 608-267-7360 | evelyn.bromberg@dot.wi.gov |
The Pooled Fund Project TPF-5(377) is led by Indiana and includes participation from FHWA, California, Connecticut, Georgia, Minnesota, NorthCarolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, Utah, andWisconsin.The projectdevelopedmethodologiesandtoolsforusinghighresolutionvehicletrajectorydata tocompute enhanced traffic signal performance measures.Significant outcomes from the study are listed at the end of this document in the reference section.
The Indiana led pooled fund traffic signal research projects have a strong history of implementation. The first study, TPF-5(259), was recognized by EDC 4 and virtually all controllers now provide high resolution data logging. There is a strong commercial base of advanced traffic signal performance measureproviders.Thetechnicalreportsfrom TPF-5(259)listedbelowarewidelydistributedandcited.
· PerformanceMeasuresforTrafficSignalSystems:AnOutcome-OrientedApproach. http://dx.doi.org/10.5703/1288284315333
· IntegratingTrafficSignalPerformanceMeasuresintoAgencyBusinessProcesses. http://dx.doi.org/10.5703/1288284316063
Similarly,TPF-5(377)isnowstimulatingasecondgenerationofcommercialimplementationoftrajectory based traffic signal performance measures.The current TPF-5(377) project end date is June 20, 2023.
DuringtheApril2022TPF-5(377) Pooled Fund StudyPanelMeetinginColumbus,OH,participatingstatesexpressedinterestin developing a new study led by a neutral state/academic partner in the following areas:
1. Broadeningperformancemeasurestoadditionalmodesthatareimpactedbytrafficsignal systems, particularly transit and pedestrians.
2. Identifyingusecasesforenhancedprobedatabeyond thecurrenttrajectoryandhard braking/hard acceleration data.
3. IntegratedAnalysisofHigh-resControllerDataandTrajectoryProbeData
Theseinitiativeswouldcomplementandexpandthepastworkthemulti-stateteamhas doneinthe area of enhanced traffic signal performance measures using connected vehicle data.
1. Identifycommercialprobedatasets thatareavailableandprocureonemonthof probedatafor each participating state. This task is important as there has been substantial growth in connected vehicle data attributes since TPF-5(377) was initiated.In addition to passenger car trajectoriesandhardbraking,therearenowdata elementsthat includefinergradationsofhard braking, finer gradations of acceleration, traction control (winter conditions), commercial truck trajectories,andelectricvehicles.Inconsultationwiththepanel,theresearchteamwillacquire as broad and inclusive connected vehicle data as financially feasible.
2. Perform penetration analysis of connected vehicle data to understand how it varies by state. There is broad interest in ensuring that the connected vehicle is representative and has sufficient penetration to provide accurate performance measures.The previous pooled fund study looked at penetration of passenger cars in the participating states (Figure 1) in August 2021.Therewasconsiderableregionalvariation(Figure2).Apreliminaryanalysisofconnected
trucksdata inIndiana,indicatedthatconnected truck datashouldalsobeconsideredtoincrease penetration.Although truck data is relatively modest during peak hours, including truck data provides a more representative analysis of how a traffic signal performs.
3. Updateperformancemeasureanalysistechniquestoexaminehowmixofcommercial vehicles and passenger cars impact a traffic signal operation.For many decades, the highway capacity manualhasusedtheheavevehicle(fhv)adjustmentfactor.However,thevalidationonthishas been quite limited.We now have an opportunity to evaluate the impact of heavy vehicles on traffic signals at scale.
4. Identify transit agencies in participating states that have AVL/connected bus data available to sharewithresearchteam.Thistaskisimportantas theinfrastructurebillhasseveralprograms that touch both transit and traffic signal systems so it is important to enhance performance measure analysis to be inclusive of transit vehicles.We anticipate this providing an important framework for factual and constructive dialog between traffic signal operators and transit operators.For example, we now have the ability to directly compare transit operating performance measures with passenger cars and trucks operating in the same stream.Figure 4 illustrates a heatmap showing bus performance measures that can be overlayed with traffic signal performance measures to identify if there are opportunities to improve traffic signal operation.
5. Integratetrajectorydataandhighresolutiondata tocharacterizehowperformancemeasures suchassplitfailureandarrival ongreenvarydepending ifthey arecalculatedusing trajectory data or traditional high resolution data. This will be important to document so agencies that have well established ATSPM programs using traditional hi-res data can easily transition to trajectory based ATSPM.
6. Integrate trajectory data and high resolution controller data for multi-modal analysis.Pedestrian push button information have long been available in hi-resolution logs, but they do not provide demand level data.Many of the new camera systems (such as Miovision) can providereasonablemeasurementofpedestrianmovementsincrosswalks.Thistaskwilllookat opportunities to integrate traffic signal data, such as pedestrian movements, with trajectory based traffic signal performance measures so that there is an opportunity for constructive and factual dialog on how to most effectively operate traffic signals in areas where pedestrian demand varies by time and location.
7. Preparefinal report.
Funding requested: $120,000($40,000peryearforthreeyears)fromeachparticipatingstate.
Proposed starting date: January1,2023
Please see the enclosed proposal.
| Title | File/Link | Type | Private |
|---|---|---|---|
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Apr - Jun 2025 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Apr - Jun 2025.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Jan - Mar 2025 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Jan - Mar 2025.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Oct - Dec 2024 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Oct - Dec 2024.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Jul - Sept 2024 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Jul - Sept 2024.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Apr - Jun 2024 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Apr - Jun 2024.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Jan - Mar 2024 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Jan - Mar 2024.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Oct - Dec 2023 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Oct - Dec 2023.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Jul - Sept 2023 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Jul - Sept 2023.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Apr - Jun 2023 | TPF 5(519) Quarterly Progress Report Apr - Jun 2023.pdf | Progress Report | Public |
| Acceptance Letter TPF-5(519) | Acceptance Letter TPF-5(519).pdf | Memorandum | Public |
| SPR Waiver Memo TPF-5(519) | State Led Approval SPR Waiver Memo#1589.TS.pdf | Memorandum | Public |
| Title | File/Link | Type | Private |
|---|---|---|---|
| Approved SP&R Waiver | State Led Approval SPR Waiver Memo#1589.TS.pdf | Memorandum | Public |
| Proposal of TPF-5(377) Expansion | Proposal of TPF-5(377) Expansion.pdf | TPF Study Documentation | Public |